Dr Nicholas Bevan

Dr Nicholas Bevan
www.nicholasbevan.com

Tuesday 2 January 2018

THE EU MOTOR INSURANCE REQUIREMENT IN A NUTSHELL

 On the scope and nature of the compulsory insurance requirement

The UK is still subject to the primacy of EU law, at least until March 2019.  As the compensatory guarantee for victims of motor vehicle accidents in the UK is still governed by the superior and binding force of EC Directive (2009/103/EC) on motor insurance, it makes sense to begin any assessment of a claimant's legal entitlement to benefit from third party cover with an analysis of its provisions.


When Article 3 of EC Directive (2009/103/EC) on motor insurance is read in the light of the underlying principles that feature in the consistent line of Court of Justice judgments from Bernaldez in 1996 through to Csonka in 2013, Vnuk in 2014 and Fidelidade in 2017 the third party cover required by the Directive is capable of being distilled into the following simple propositions: 

1.         All motor insurance policies are required to provide a holistic guarantee for the assured's civil liability arising out of the insured vehicles' use.  Article 3 requires each member state to ensure that its national law requires such cover for:
a.         Any motor vehicle conforming with the wide definition in article 1 (mechanically propelled vehicle and intended for travel on land)
b.         Any use made of that vehicle that is consistent with the normal function of the vehicle
c.         Anywhere on land
d.         That the third party victim's entitlement to the insurance guarantee extends to:
 (i) liability for defects in the vehicle itself and 
(ii) liability for unauthorised users and 
(iii) liability for other non-contractual use
2.         The user’s duty to insure and the scope of cover that the insurer is required to provide are coextensive.
3.         Member states have no discretion to introduce their own restrictions, exclusions or limitations.
·         Only one exclusion of cover is permitted: this applies to a passenger who voluntarily enters the vehicle knowing that it has been stolen (Article 13 of the Directive).
·         Subject to this single derogation, once issued, the policy must confer on third party victims an irrevocable guarantee of their compensatory entitlement, up to the minimum levels prescribed by Article 9, regardless of any breaches of policy term or misinformation or fraud at the policy's inception

The CJEU ruled in Candolin that any other exclusion of insurer liability, whether contractual or statutory, is void.  As CJEU rulings have direct effect, this principle is capable of being applied as part and parcel of our national law provision.  The CJEU explained the rationale thus:

‘18     In view of the aim of protecting victims, the Court has held that Article 3(1) of the First Directive precludes an insurer from relying on statutory provisions or contractual clauses in order to refuse to compensate third-party victims of an accident caused by the insured vehicle (Ruiz Bernáldez, paragraph 20)
‘20     By way of derogation from that obligation, the second subparagraph of Article 2(1) [NCB note: this is now set out in Article 13 of the Directive] provides that certain persons may be excluded from compensation by the insurer, having regard to the situation they have themselves brought about (persons entering a vehicle which they know to have been stolen) (Ruiz Bernáldez, paragraph 21).
21     However, as it is a provision which establishes a derogation from a general rule, the second subparagraph of Article 2(1) of the Second Directive must be interpreted strictly.’

The rationale in Candolin is just as capable of being applied to the MIB scheme as it is to a contractual or statutory provision regulating compulsory insurance. 

It is a surprising fact that it does not appear to have occurred to any claimant to invoke Candolin to challenge an unlawful exclusion of liability, within a motor insurance policy, the Road Traffic Act or one of the MIB Agreements. If all exclusions and restrictions in liability that are not expressly provided for within the Directive are void, then our national courts would appear to be bound by the horizontal effect of the Court of Justice's ruling in Candolin to excise the unlawful term when construing the policy terms. This issue has been referred to the Court of Justice by Ireland in David Smith v Patrick Meade & anor; FBD Insurance PLC (Case C-122-17) for a preliminary ruling.

It is clear from the CJEU judgments in Churchill and Csonka that the Directive requires the compensatory protection to be provided at an anterior stage, namely within the insurance policy itself.  It follows that the Article 10 compensating body responsible for compensating victims of uninsured and unidentified vehicles (which in the UK is the Motor Insurers’ Bureau) is a’ last resort’; not a catch-all for insufficiently insured vehicles. 


I am working a series of lectures on this important topic that will also explain how best to deploy the three main EU law remedies that enable private individuals to invoke, in a cost effective and proportionate manner, the superior authority of EU law in ordinary civil actions against insurers, the MIB and the Secretary of State for Transport.

7 comments:

  1. Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles as long as I provide credit and sources back to your wepost? My post site is in the very same area of interest as yours and my visitors would definitely benefit from some of the information you present here. Please let me know if this alright with you. Appreciate it! examples of great customer service

    ReplyDelete
  2. Onlinelicpolicy.in is an online platform which is specially formed to provide knowledge and services to those individuals who want to take LIC policy or who are already policyholder.
    VIEW MORE:- lic bima shree maturity calculator

    Thankyou..

    ReplyDelete
  3. Check out the profiles that are mentioned on the website and then select one that attracts you the most. Our agency has some of the city’s most sexy escorts who are here to offer the enchanting and wonderful services. One thing that we guarantee is that you will get the most amazing time of your life with our girls. No one can beat our Islamabad Escorts and you will trust that after spending a single night with our girls. You can take one of our sexy girls to a wonderful party or a dance bar where you can perform erotic steps with them. It is one of some reasons that makes us one of the best Lahore Escorts agency.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have just searching such information and here you describe it in very easy way. Thank you for sharing such information with us.

    Tax Advocate in India

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. thanks for shearing your ideas and experience.i like it .
    meet and greet at luton

    ReplyDelete
  7. It was one of the great blog.Thanks for sharing the blog, seems to be interesting and informative too.Could you help me to find more detail about Motor Insurance

    ReplyDelete